Welcome to STOR-IES™, the blog of The iNNOVATION Shop.

If You Know Reviewer 2, You Know

|Eulanda A. Sanders, Ph.D.

When the reviews come back on a journal article, most of us start in the same place. We read Reviewer 1.

Reviewer 1 is usually fine. There may be a request to clarify a definition, a suggestion to add a few recent citations, or a polite note that the discussion could be a little stronger. You nod, make a list, and think, I can have this finished by Friday.

Then you scroll down to Reviewer 2.

Reviewer 2 does not want a few recent citations. Reviewer 2 wants to know why you chose this theoretical framework instead of the one they had in mind. Reviewer 2 would like additional data, a reorganized literature review, and possibly a different research question altogether. By the time you reach the last comment, your Friday deadline has quietly become next semester.

The Reviewer Everyone Recognizes

Reviewer 2 is not a specific person. The actual reviewer changes with every submission. Still, mention Reviewer 2 to almost any researcher, and you will get a knowing laugh, because the character has become part of academic folklore. Reviewer 2 is the one with the most demanding comments, the sharpest tone, and the longest list of things you apparently should have done differently.

To be fair, the second reviewer is sometimes the most generous person in the process, and Reviewer 1 can be every bit as tough. A demanding review often catches something that genuinely needed attention, and the paper is better for it.

However, acknowledging that would spoil a perfectly good joke, so we will let Reviewer 2 keep the reputation.

Juror 2 Has Entered the Gallery

Journal articles are only one part of scholarly life for those of us in design. As a textile and apparel designer, I also submit creative scholarship to juried exhibitions, where designers and artists send their work to experts in the field for evaluation and acceptance into gallery exhibitions. Jurors consider originality, concept, craftsmanship, technical execution, and whether the piece communicates what it set out to communicate.

I can tell you that Reviewer 2 has a cousin. Juror 2 is often just as tough.

One juror may respond to the concept or an unexpected choice of materials. Another may look at the same piece and question the relationship between idea and execution, or wonder why it was submitted at all. Same garment, same artist statement, two very different readings.

Creative work makes this feel especially personal. A single design can hold months of research, sampling, and problem-solving before a juror ever sees it. When the critique comes back sharp, it lands on all of that time at once.

Why We Made a Collection About It

At some point, the most reasonable response to Reviewer 2 is to laugh. That is why we created the REVIEWER 2 collection at The iNNOVATION Shop. We thought it would be funny to acknowledge the challenges Reviewer 2 so often brings, in journal articles and juried exhibitions alike, and to give the people who have lived through them something to wear about it.

The designs read a little like lines lifted from a decision letter. Reviewer 2 Remains Unconvinced.™ is for anyone who revised, responded, added evidence, and still did not get the nod. Reviewer 2: The Reason My Paper Took Three More Years.™ needs no explanation for anyone who has watched a manageable revision stretch across several academic calendars. And for my fellow designers and exhibiting artists, Reviewer 2: Read It Differently.™ is for every time your work was interpreted in a way you never intended.

These shirts work a bit like a secret handshake. Wear one to a conference, a faculty meeting, or a gallery opening, and the people who understand will understand immediately. Nobody needs the joke explained.

Rigor, With a Sense of Humor

None of this is an argument against peer review. I have spent more than 36 years in academia and education, and I believe careful evaluation makes both scholarship and creative work stronger. What I would ask of every reviewer and juror, whatever their number, is that they challenge the work without diminishing the person who made it. There is a real difference between rigor and rudeness.

In the meantime, we can at least enjoy the shared experience. Open the decision letter. Read Reviewer 1. Take a breath, refill your coffee, and then scroll down.

If you know, you know.

If Reviewer 2 has ever rearranged your plans, you will find a few familiar comments waiting in the REVIEWER 2 collection at The iNNOVATION Shop.

 

Keep innovating!

Eulanda

0 comments

Leave a comment

NEW + FEATURED

View all